PROSPECTIVE STUDENTS     CURRENT STUDENTS     ALUMNI & FRIENDS     COMMUNITY     FACULTY & STAFF
 

« Miners captured in action | Main | Hi, hi, let us celebrate pi »

The trouble with tornados

From the editors: Severe weather ripped through Missouri, Arkansas and Illinois this weekend, tearing off roofs and leaving several dead (read about it here, here or here). With the early start to the Midwest's tornado season, we asked Donald C. Wunsch II, the M.K. Finley Missouri Distinguished Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering at UMR, to share his insights into tornado prediction.

Every tornado season, we hear stories of their destructive wrath. As video cameras have improved, we’ve seen much more dramatic clips, attesting to their power. And, all too predictably, we hear of deaths attributable to their fury.

The problem is that tornados are as unpredictable as these stories are predictable. They are highly nonlinear phenomena, and while patterns that give rise to them can be identified, there is a high false alarm rate. False alarms are very bad when the goal is to generate a warning. They create a “Boy Who Called Wolf" problem – people learn to ignore them, and then fail to respond when the situation is truly dire.

I used to live in Lubbock, Texas, site of one of the nation’s worst tornado disasters in the mid-70s. During the late ‘90s, my student and I did a research project on this, and reported on it in: “Tornado Prediction: A Markov Decision Process," Zhanyu Ge, Donald Wunsch, Loren Philips, The Conference on Severe Weather, Lubbock, TX, February 9-11, 1999.

It turns out that we can address the fundamental scientific problems in tornado detection, which would probably lead to some increased warnings. The more vexing problem is in software.

I’m fond of saying that we’re still in the stone ages of software. One of the most serious problems is one that we encountered in this project. Basically, the National Severe Storms Laboratory in Oklahoma collects high-quality data on such storms. However, this data is not easily accessible for training neural networks or other machine learning algorithms. The problem is that software development costs are high, simply for developing the interface. In addition to the costs of software development increasing over time, because it is so labor intensive, there are also hurdles that a technically unnecessary – namely, that different systems don’t talk to each other very well. This means that having someone trained in statistics and machine learning techniques isn’t sufficient – you might also need a full-time software engineer.

We will get past these barriers and create many new solutions, mostly software based, that address problems like tornado detection. The techniques are improving all the time. But, if and when these barriers are finally lowered, get ready for a blistering increase in the rate of progress.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blog.mst.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/115

Comments

I was in the Lubbock Tornado. I was 5 years old, and it is my first clear memory. I remember being woke from my sleep, pulled from my bed and thrown into a car that sped off to an underground tornado shelter. We spent most of that night sitting in the shelter and listening to the radio as what seemed like tornado after tornado passed through Lubbock. I remember driving around Lubbock and seeing the devestation and realizing even as a young child the furocity of the storm. My hat is off to anybody who has worked to make life safer in the path of tornados.
nice pictures and video clips work on the whole writing part
Great Clip i am From a Small city in Oklahoma and when i was about 8 we had one of the biggest Tornados ever just muss us. It hit Catosa Oklahoma head on. "the last scene in Twister was based on it" at the time my babysiter live in Catosa. her home was the only one standing in her neighbor hood the Tornado hit at 4:30pm we left her house at 4:00. While in Oklahoma i was in 12 tornados had the fence and deck in our backyard destroyed 6 times and yet our house never recieved and major damage. but the real fun is going out there and trying to find one and when you do its an awesome sight to see. I loved living in Tornado Alley

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Please enter the letter "c" in the field below: